Site Meter Pride & Opinions » Blog Archive » Identity Politics and GLBT Voting

Identity Politics and GLBT Voting

by

What with all the focus on identity politics in this election season, it only makes sense that although neither of the candidates stirring up the constant discussions of race v. gender identify as GLBT, or really anything other than strictly heterosexual, there would be focus on GLBT voting patterns. I see it as part of the larger question about what the purpose of progressive voting is - what obligation to those folks who wish to vote progressively have to being realistic, and what expectation should underserved populations have at being catered to by mainstream candidates.

For GLBT folks, this is especially pronounced, since gays make up such a small portion of the overall population, and so much hatred is targeted at the notion of gay rights and gay families from the right. Should GLBT progressives suck it up and vote for the Democratic candidate without demanding much focus on GLBT issues because they’re so much better than the alternative, or is that asking too much? Some would say it is too much, and I totally understand that opinion.

Terrance at The Republic of T has an excellent post on this titled “Voting for Ourselves.” In it, he argues,

As gay man with a partner and a family, that comes in to very sharp focus. But as I look around I can’t help wondering why so few of us are doing he same, and why. Far be it from me to tell anyone else how to vote or who to vote for, but when buckets of gay dollars and hordes of gay volunteers touch down in Iowa, and a major gay organization appears to be deploying resources in New Hampshire, for a candidate who can’t even divorce herself from DOMA (and who may be “the least supportive? of the Democratic candidates [Via Queerty.]), I find myself wondering if the Republicans aren’t the only geniuses at persuading people to vote against their own interests.

Two major candidates have at least come out in favor of a full repeal of DOMA. That’s not support for marriage equality, but it’s a step towards removing a significant barrier to marriage equality. How, then, do we support a candidate who would leave most of that barrier in place, given the problems that “leaving it to the states? creates for our families?

It’s a good article. Read the whole thing.

What do you think? Is sacrificing the most progressive of your political opinions, or support for your identity group, worth the larger practical political goal? Or is it too much to ask?

GLBT, politics, primaries, progressive politics

, , ,


Leave a Reply


About Pride & Opinions

This site discusses news and politics surrounding various GBLT issues.

Pride & Opinions Author(s)

Blogging Flair

Links to Site

Questions, comments, criticisms, topic ideas for Pride and Opinions, as well as professions of love for Michael that are not fit for the comments section may be sent to Michael via the Contact Me link above. Hate mail will be ignored unless I find you pitiful enough to poke fun of.

Gay & Lesbian Channel Posts

  • Clay Aiken's Gay
    So now that he's a daddy himself, now that five years of speculation have been swept under the rug, now that he's had a successful reprisal of his role as Sir Robin in Monty Python's Spamalot, now [...]
  • Halos and Horns - Brad Pitt Supports Gay Marriage
    You read the headline right.  Movie superstar heartthrob and Angelina Jolie baby daddy Brad Pitt is not only easy on the eyes and a pretty darned good actor, he also has a special place in his [...]
  • Funny Commercials
    I saw this today and couldn't resist sharing it.  I know I've been neglecting you, my pretties and I sincerely apologize from the bottom of my Sex on the Beach. Maybe this makes it up a little [...]
  • Will & Grace star auctions his car for AIDS Charity
    Actor Eric McCormack who played Will on the popular NBC television series Will & Grace is a big believer in giving back. According to a statement released recently, McCormack put his prized [...]
  • Michael's Big Gay Pride and Opinions Link Contest
    How's this for shameless self-promotion? I am hereby announcing the first-ever link contest here at Pride and Opinions! As we all know, web sites only grow when people know about them and I want [...]
  • Introducing the Pride and Opinions Blidget!
    I know your type. You're the early adopter, techno-geek who probably sat in line for three days to get the new iPhone 3G. Well now you've got something new to add to your web arsenal, in the form [...]
  • Alternative sexuality conference to be held November 8th in The Greater City of Sudbury, ON.
    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Sudbury, ON - September 1, 2008 - The Northern Ontario Conference of Kink (NOCK) will be held on November 8, 2008, from noon to midnight, in Chelmsford, ON, 25 minutes [...]
  • Michael's Gayest Albums Evar - Volume 1
    The current issue of OUT Magazine contains a cover piece touting the "100 Gayest Albums of All Time", so I thought I would take a look at some of what I consider to be the gayest of them [...]
  • Pride & Opinions Hurricane Party Music - Volume 1
    You know us gays - it doesn't take much for us to have a party.  In fact, sometimes we just have a party because there is nothing else to do. This time it seems as though Hurricane Gustav is [...]
  • Atlanta Gay Business Owner Arrested on Federal Charges
    Gay businessman Ben Elliott - who left the Atlanta area immediately after the controversial closing of popular gay bar Hoedown's last year - was arrested Wednesday on federal charges of wire fraud [...]

Hot Off The Press